October 28, 2007

What's in a name?

Today's issue of The New York Times Magazine contained an article about gender neutral names and there specific connotations. The increasing popularity of these names, the article suggests, is that “it’s not a disgrace to be a girl anymore.”

Being a girl is a disgrace if children are being teased for having typically feminine names. As the text points out, it's usually the boys with gender-neutral names who get teased, not the girls. In other words, it's OK for "girls to be boys" (as long as their masculinity is canceled out by stereotypically female behavior), but not "boys to be girls,” because there’s something inherently wrong with femaleness or femininity.

What does this article say about gender roles? A name only has the connotation we give it. When a baby boy is born, he doesn’t think, “Ooh, my name’s Kelly, better start buying my tap shoes early!” Children are taught how to behave because of gender-based toys and clothing and adult role models, not a certain combo of letters that only means what we as society says it does.

If the name really does make the child, be sure to keep little Fidel away from the tinker toys.

12 comments:

Anonymous said...

cameron....sam....noah....brooke...austin...alex...dylan..wow there r a lot of grl/boy names

Anonymous said...

I don't think Sam/Alex count because they're nicknames attributed to gender-specific names--Sam and Samantha, Alex and Alexandra (or Alexis).

Emily said...

So what's the main thing we can take out of this post? Don't use gender neutral names? Stop enforcing stereotypes while the child is in utero?

Molly said...

or you could just not have children! that would solve this problem completely!

Anonymous said...

no i don't think it really matters if a girl ha a guy name or vice versa. depending on the cild's interests , the name will evolve into THEIR name and not a neutral gender name.

Anonymous said...

I think the whole point is that when gender stereotypes are prevalent in our culture, gender-neutral names do no good.

Anonymous said...

so basically ur saying people with gender neutral names lives are chosen by those around them not by their own choices witch is impossible basically

Anonymous said...

how so? studies show girls with uber-feminine names like candy dont pursue math or science as deeply

Anonymous said...

I have a guy anem and i'm not at all interested in guy things. im actually pretty girly. so i don't really think ( again) that it depends on the gender of the name, it depends on the interests.

Anonymous said...

* name

Anonymous said...

It's a case-by-case basis, a general trend that may or may not apply to you.

Emily said...

In response to "anonymous's" post (and please use the "other" option in the future so we can call you by your name), it's not so much that it is impossible to choose your own life, it's that our lives are very much affected by societies standards. The only way we'd ever, TRULY be able to live without societies influence is if we lived in a vaccuum. Since that's not the case, affected we must be.